Home / Blog / Cost-Effectiveness of Masonry

Cost-Effectiveness of Masonry

A masonry wall gives the appearance of brick

One of the longstanding perceptions surrounding concrete-based construction is that greater durability and fire resistance come with a significantly higher initial construction cost. An independent construction cost study set out to test that assumption. 

The 2017 Initial Cost of Construction: Multi-Residential Structures study evaluated the relative construction costs of a multifamily building using six different construction systems. The systems included conventional wood framing, light-gauge steel framing, loadbearing concrete masonry with precast concrete plank floors, precast concrete construction and two insulated concrete form options. 

Comparing Construction Systems

To provide a consistent comparison, the study used a four-story multifamily residential building of approximately 25,000 square feet per floor. The model incorporated a mix of one- and two-bedroom units and was designed to represent apartments, condominiums, student housing, senior housing and similar multifamily applications. 

Cost estimates were developed for Dallas, Texas; Edgewater, New Jersey; and Towson, Maryland, with pricing evaluated at three points between December 2016 and September 2017 to account for changing construction costs. 

The results demonstrated that concrete masonry could compete closely with lighter-weight construction systems on initial cost. In the May 2017 estimates, the loadbearing concrete masonry and precast plank system was the lowest-cost system in all three markets studied. By September 2017, the results varied by market: the masonry and precast system remained below conventional wood framing in Edgewater, while coming in slightly above wood framing in Dallas and Towson. 

Looking Beyond Initial Cost

The study’s broader finding was that noncombustible, concrete-based construction did not necessarily carry the large cost premium often assumed. The researchers also pointed to benefits beyond initial construction cost, including fire resistance, durability, resistance to mold and vandalism and the potential for reduced damage and faster reoccupation following a fire. 

Why Market Conditions Matter

Because construction costs vary by location and over time, the original findings should not be read as current pricing. The researchers subsequently expanded the study with market-specific addenda across the United States and Canada. Later analyses also incorporated builder’s risk and property insurance costs to examine how construction type can influence costs beyond the initial build. 

Those later studies continued to demonstrate that masonry and precast construction can be cost-competitive depending on the market. For example, a 2022 Honolulu analysis found the masonry and precast system competitive with conventional wood framing on initial construction cost and lower when construction and 10 years of property insurance were considered together. 

The takeaway remains much the same as it was when the original study was published: assumptions about the cost of concrete masonry should be tested against the actual project and market. Material prices, labor, insurance, building configuration and regional conditions all affect the equation. 

For owners and designers, concrete masonry can deliver durability, resilience and fire-resistant construction without automatically putting the project at a cost disadvantage. 

REFERENCES 

Categories:

Related Content

  • Reducing Potential for Efflorescence

    A white, powdery deposit across an otherwise clean masonry façade can be frustrating, but understanding why efflorescence…

  • Is Concrete Block Better Than Wood Frame?

    Cost Savings & Availability Make Concrete Masonry Ideal for Demanding Building Applications